WindWorks Trumpet Academy Forums WindWorks open blow or trumpet with a lot of resitance?

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • Author
    • #108927

      Hi Greg,

      I know it is personal, but to you. Do you prefer a open blowing trumpet or a trumpet with more ‘resistance’. I happen to have 2 trumpets 🙂 1 very open blow and 1 with a lot of (percieved) resistance. At first my range was higher on the trumpet with resistance and surely the slotting and tuning was easier. That is my ‘daily’ trumpet. But having done MTM for some months again, and by picking up the other (open blow) trumpet all of a sudden range seemed a lot easier. For myself I can not tell which one to prefer really. I am just curious if you have any thoughts or advice on this?

      Thanks for sharing your opinion,



    • #117637

      I have a Bobby Shew Z Yamaha which has a somewhat restricted blow – Bobby had it designed after he got emphysema, I heard. And I have a Bach Strad 43 ML which blows a bit more freely. I move between the two fairly often. I think the Yammie is easier to play, but I sound a bit better – more open and rich – on the Bach. This is not any help, I know, but I just wanted to put my experience down here.

      Mostly, I play jazz with the Yammie and legit with the Bach. I don’t think I have any range or endurance differences with the two horns, but the Yammie is, as i said, a bit easier to get around on.

      FTR, I’m an “intermediate” comeback player – off for 30 years, back now for 23. I’ll be 78 next week. Struggled with all of it forever, but am finding the easier approach the MTM brings to be very helpful. At least for now – I’ve just been in this group a couple of weeks.

      (I do have a Martin Standard from 1938 that I got from a family member that is HUGE. Just so tough to play that I put it away. Really requires a LOT of air. Now that you’ve started this discussion, I might get it out and try it with MTM. Thanks.)


      Bill in Albuquerque

Viewing 1 reply thread
  • You must be logged in to reply to this topic.

Recent replies